A closer look at the global rush toward youth social media restrictions

Brazil, Canada and the EU show foundational alignment as more governments move to limit or halt children's exposure to social media.

Contributors:
Lexie White
Staff Writer
IAPP
The expanded use of personalized algorithms and AI chatbots are among the considerations driving global policymakers' work to protect children across social media platforms. While there is no one-size-fits-all regulatory framework, common threads are developing across jurisdictions to address the emerging safety risks children and parents are facing.
A recent report from the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development highlighted proposed social media age restrictions more than doubled in the last year from 10 to 22. Australia, Brazil and Indonesia enacted new safeguards for underage users while several jurisdictions, including the EU and Canada, introduced proposals for consideration.
Many of the proposed frameworks are accompanied by complementary measures, including age assurance requirements, consent obligations and advanced parental controls.
The child safety initiatives taken up in Brazil, Canada and the EU were discussed at length during the latest installment of the OECD's Growing Up Online webinar series.
Unpacking the EU Kids Act
European Commission Head of Sector for the Protection of Minors Online Martin Harris Hess highlighted the sprawling nature of the Commission's KIDS Act proposal, which introduces limitations around children's access to social media, AI chatbots and certain gaming platforms.
"The risk profile of the individual services differ, and therefore the regulatory response differs as well," he said, noting the proposed regulation addresses online safety measures through a safety-by-design lens.
"It's not just about age-gating services and excluding children or stopping children from accessing certain services that are perceived to be too risky for them to access," Harris Hess added. "But it is actually about making the online environment a safer space for children so that they can participate in it safely."
With the KIDS Act, children under age 13 would be prohibited from creating social media accounts while users 13 to 14 could access limited accounts through a guardian's account.
The bill would allow children over age 15 to create their own accounts, though platforms must implement age-appropriate design controls.
Harris Hess noted the EU is also looking to introduce privacy-preserving age verification methods, including zero-knowledge proof mechanisms to verify users' ages and ensure additional personal data is not shared in the process.
Under the proposed obligations, organizations would also be required to implement time management tools, parental controls and reporting systems for underage users.
Brazil's Digital ECA and age assurance
Brazil's Digital Child and Adolescent Statute, which went into force in March, establishes similar age assurance and risk management measures to those proposed in the KIDS Act.
The Digital ECA requires organizations to implement safeguards to combat risks associated with their platforms, including parental controls. Its robust age assurance requirements are notable, according to Lorena Giuberti Coutinho, a commissioner at Brazil's data protection authority, the Agência Nacional de Proteção de Dados.
Platforms with content or services that could be considered inappropriate for underage users must enlist age verification mechanisms. Verification is done through age signals, which Coutinho said can be "shared via application programming interfaces with applications and websites to support the implementation of age-appropriate experiences."
She added that age assurance in general "should be proportionate to the risks involved" and "not seen as a standalone solution."
Canada's approach
The proposed Bill C-34, the Safe Social Media Act, would block children under age 16 from maintaining accounts on certain social media platforms while introducing additional obligations for live-streaming and AI chatbot platforms.
Canadian Heritage Digital Citizens Initiative Manager Frederick Matern noted the bill would be required to roll out effective age assurance systems that bolster child safety "at the core of how services are designed, and that entails designing platforms and features that prioritize the protection of children's physical and mental health." Similar to Brazil's Digital ECA, the bill would evaluate platform's applicability based on a given service's risks.
"Regulated services operating in Canada would need to assess, mitigate and respond to serious risk of harm arising from the design and operation of their services, and they also have to be transparent about what they do," Matern said.
Bill C-34 also looks to establish the Digital Safety Commission to oversee enforcement, assess compliance, and provide exemptions for companies that have implemented adequate safeguards.
The commission "will be able to make guidelines and specify exactly how and in what form many of these requirements are done," according to Matern. "But it'll also set standards, and it will do a lot of outreach, guidance, and public education to help users navigate these sometimes very complex systems."
This content is eligible for Continuing Professional Education credits. Please self-submit according to CPE policy guidelines.
Word count: 970

Contributors:
Lexie White
Staff Writer
IAPP



