UK lawmakers question Big Tech representatives on OSA compliance work

With the Online Safety Act set to become fully enforceable mid-2027, members of the U.K. House of Lords asked witnesses to discuss how their respective companies were handling the children's safety requirements to this point.

Contributors:
Alex LaCasse
Staff Writer
IAPP
With the U.K. Online Safety Act set to fully take force by spring 2027, representatives from three Big Tech firms testified in a 17 Nov. hearing before the House of Lords' Communications and Digital Committee. The discussion included check-ins on practices to comply with the OSA's required duty of care as well as the incoming child social media ban for users under age 16, which came through an amendment to the OSA earlier this year.
During the hearing, committee members pressed Google, Meta and Roblox on questions related to the extent to which each company was taking proactive measures to keep children safe online. Questions also focused on a report issued by the Office of Communications last month outlining the current state of compliance with the OSA among tech companies.
The report states the Ofcom has "not observed any significant changes in the incidence or severity of any kind of content over the first nine months after the children's or safety duties came into force in July 2025." It contains several recommendations for improving the OSA, but notably indicates the potential impacts AI chatbots may have on children should not be considered at this point under the act.
"We recognize that children are not safe on the platforms they're using. … I feel action is necessary, but in the longer-term children should not be banned, that's the feeling a lot of us have," House of Lords member Barbara Keeley told the witnesses. "Your companies should be responsible for what you create and the impacts that it has."
Compliance approaches
Google Director for government Affairs and Public Policy Katie O'Donovan said the OSA is a "serious piece of legislation" and a "very deep regulation." Her company has strived to embrace a safety-by-design approach even before the OSA passed. However, she said the OSA has compelled Google to "change the way we operate," with respect to how teams are organized and compliance efforts.
New safety measures adopted by Google include "locking on" safe search by default for users under 18 by using age inference techniques when the age of the user is unknown to the company. It also built an improved portal for users to notify the company when they encounter nonconsensual imagery through Google Search and improved the recommender system on YouTube to elevate "good-quality content" while reducing "low-quality content."
Additionally, O'Donovan said YouTube's algorithm was modified so content "viewed in isolation" that is not harmful, such as a fitness video, are recommended less frequently if the user is compulsively watching multiple such videos that could signal a body image health issue.
"Obviously the Online Safety Act regulates a huge number of companies and a huge number of services, and we are one of the most frequently used, but not one of the highest harms," O'Donovan said. "But through actions we're taking because of the Online Safety Act, and because of our own safety ways of working, our users are increasingly able to use safer platforms."
For Meta, Director of U.K. Public Policy Rebecca Stimson indicated that while the OSA's risk assessment requirements may be among the "least visible" aspects of the law, they have "codified into law a very robust and extensive process of risk management and risk assessment" for every new product the company seeks to introduce in the U.K.
Committee members questioned Stimson regarding the open Ofcom investigation into alleged inadequate OSA risk assessments conducted before the company launched Instagram's "Instants" feature in the U.K. Under the act, assessments for child risks and illegal content were supposed to come as the company made "a significant change to any aspect of a service's design or operation."
Stimson said Meta has invested upward of 30 billion GBP on safety and security in recent years while dedicating approximately 40,000 employees to tackle children's online safety issues throughout the company. The new safety measures include limiting certain features in teen-specific accounts and enabling parental controls that set activity limits as short as 15 minutes for their children, as examples where the company has gone beyond the minimum requirements of the OSA.
"We're currently in a conversation with (Ofcom) about … how we can ensure we balance people's ability to use the platform as a social network, but not connecting them to people they shouldn't be connected to and putting them in harm's way," Stimson said. "We don't take the requirements in the Online Safety Act as a ceiling, they are a helpful floor."
Roblox Senior Director for Public Policy for Europe, the Middle East and Africa Tim Scott said the OSA has compelled his company to roll out several new features geared toward keeping children safe on its platform.
Over the last 18 months, Roblox has introduced facial age estimation and age assurance features that allow the company to "restrict certain features and functionalities for people on our platform." These features, he said, have enabled the company to effectively split the platform into two different experiences — Roblox Kids and Roblox Select, which offer different functionalities and features depending on the ascertained age of the user.
"Safety is a continually moving target and it's something that we're constantly chasing and pursuing," Scott said. "That's why the Online Safety Act is a crucial function in how we respond to (the law), but also how we look at (safety) globally. We have users from all around the world and having something so detailed and rich as the Online Safety Act helps us appreciate how we might apply this in a global setting."
This content is eligible for Continuing Professional Education credits. Please self-submit according to CPE policy guidelines.
Word count: 917

Contributors:
Alex LaCasse
Staff Writer
IAPP
Tags:



